-
Ophthalmic & Physiological Optics : the... Nov 2014Measurement properties of tests to assess reading acuity or reading performance have not been extensively evaluated. This study aims to provide an overview of the... (Review)
Review
PURPOSE
Measurement properties of tests to assess reading acuity or reading performance have not been extensively evaluated. This study aims to provide an overview of the literature on available continuous text reading tests and their measurement properties.
METHODS
A literature search was performed in PubMed, Embase and PsycInfo. Subsequently, information on design and content of reading tests, study design and measurement properties were extracted using consensus-based standards for selection of health measurement instruments. Quality of studies, reading tests and measurement properties were systematically assessed using pre-specified criteria.
RESULTS
From 2334 identified articles, 20 relevant articles were found on measurement properties of three reading tests in various languages: IReST, MNread Reading Test and Radner Reading Charts. All three reading tests scored high on content validity. Reproducibility studies (repeated measurements between different testing sessions) of the IReST and MNread of commercially available reading tests in different languages were missing. The IReST scored best on inter-language comparison, the MNread scored well in repeatability studies (repeated measurements under the same conditions) and the Radner showed good reproducibility in studies.
CONCLUSIONS
Although in daily practice there are other continuous text reading tests available meeting the criteria of this review, measurement properties were described in scientific studies for only three of them. Of the few available studies, the quality and content of study design and methodology used varied. For testing existing reading tests and the development of new ones, for example in other languages, we make several recommendations, including careful description of patient characteristics, use of objective and subjective lighting levels, good control of working distance, documentation of the number of raters and their training, careful documentation of scoring rules and the use of Bland-Altman analyses or similar for reproducibility and repeatability studies.
Topics: Humans; Reading; Reproducibility of Results; Vision Tests; Visual Acuity
PubMed: 25331578
DOI: 10.1111/opo.12158 -
Clinical & Experimental Optometry Apr 2022Measuring reading ability is a crucial part of assessing patients who complain of reduced vision. Foreign language versions of such charts need to be developed and...
CLINICAL RELEVANCE
Measuring reading ability is a crucial part of assessing patients who complain of reduced vision. Foreign language versions of such charts need to be developed and validated.
BACKGROUND
It is difficult to measure or predict Korean reading ability due to a lack of a representative reading charts in Korean, and previous charts have limited capacity to detect deficits in reading ability among Korean patients with eye diseases.
METHODS
Two printed versions of the reading chart were created. Thirty-four patients with no change in vision in the last three months and no expected change in vision in the next four weeks were included in this study. The results were validated by testing 13 normal-sighted adults (group 1), 14 patients with various macular diseases whose visual acuity was equal or better than 0.5 logarithm of the minimum angle of resolution (logMAR) (group 2), and seven patients with various macular diseases whose visual acuities were between 1.3 logMAR and 0.5 logMAR (group 3). Inter-chart and intra-subject repeatabilities were assessed for maximum reading speed (MRS) and critical print size (CPS).
RESULTS
A total of 38 sentences were tested on 34 adults in three groups. Groups 1 and 2 did not differ significantly in terms of MRS and CPS. The MRS was lower in group 3, for each chart and between visits. The CPS was larger in group 3, for each chart and between visits, with the exception of chart 2 during visit one. With regard to test-retest reliability, the intraclass correlation co-efficients (ICCs) for chart 1 and chart 2 were more than 0.900. With regard to inter-chart reliability, the ICCs were more than 0.892, respectively.
CONCLUSION
The reading chart developed in this study was reliable in producing consistent results among a normal Korean population and patients with various macular diseases.
Topics: Adult; Humans; Language; Reading; Reproducibility of Results; Republic of Korea; Vision Tests
PubMed: 33941049
DOI: 10.1080/08164622.2021.1908821 -
Military Medicine Jan 2023Color vision deficiency (CVD) is a disqualifying condition for military special duty occupations. Color vision testing and standards vary slightly among the U.S....
INTRODUCTION
Color vision deficiency (CVD) is a disqualifying condition for military special duty occupations. Color vision testing and standards vary slightly among the U.S. military branches. Paper-based pseudoisochromatic plates (PIPs) remain a screening tool. Computer-based color vision tests (CVTs), i.e., the Cone Contrast Test (CCT), the Colour Assessment and Diagnosis (CAD) test, and the Waggoner Computerized Color Vision Test (WCCVT), are now replacing the Farnsworth Lantern Test (FALANT) and its variants to serve as a primary or secondary test in the U.S. Armed Forces. To maintain consistency in recruitment, performance, and safety, the study objectives were to examine military color vision testing, passing criteria, and color discrimination performance.
METHODS
Study participants were 191 (17% female) students, faculty, and staff of the U.S. Air Force Academy and the Naval Aerospace Medical Institute. All subjects performed six CVTs, and 141 participants completed two additional military relevant color discrimination tasks. Friedman non-parametric test and Wilcoxon signed-rank post hoc test with Bonferroni adjusted P values were used to compare CVTs and standards. Analysis of variance and Bonferroni adjusted post hoc test were used to describe effects on color discrimination performance.
RESULTS
The Heidelberg Multicolor-Moreland and Rayleigh (HMC-MR) anomaloscope diagnosed 58 CVD (30.4%). There were no statistically significant differences in identifying red-green CVD by the HMC-MR, CCT, CAD, WCCVT, and PIP tests (P = .18), or classifying deutan, protan, and normal color vision (CVN) by the HMC-MR and the CVT (P = .25). Classification of tritan CVD was significantly different depending on which CVT was used (P < .001). Second, overall passing rates were 79.1% on the CAD (≤6 standard normal unit (SNU)), 78.5% on the combined PIP/FALANT, 78.0% on the CCT (≥55%), and 75.4% on the WCCVT (mild) military standards. The CVTs and the PIP/FALANT standards were not significantly different in number of personnel selected, but CAD and CCT passed significantly more individuals than WCCVT (P = .011 and P = .004, respectively). The previous U.S. Air Force standard (CCT score ≥75%) passed significantly fewer individuals relative the U.S. Navy pre-2017 PIP/FALANT or the current CVT standards (P ≤ .001). Furthermore, for those who failed the PIP (<12/14), the FALANT (9/9 or ≥16/18) agreed with the CVTs on passing the same CVN (n = 5); however, it also passed moderate-to-severe CVD who did not pass WCCVT (n = 6), CCT (n = 3), and CAD (n = 1). Lastly, moderate/severe CVD were significantly slower and less accurate than the "mild" CVD or CVN in the two color discrimination tasks (P < .001). In comparison to CVN in the in-cockpit display color discrimination task, mild CVD (CCT ≥55% and <75%) were significantly slower by 1,424 ± 290 milliseconds in reaction time (P < .001) while maintaining accuracy.
CONCLUSIONS
CVTs are superior to paper-based PIP in diagnosing, classifying, and grading CVD. Relative to the PIP/FALANT standard in personnel selection, the current U.S. military CVT passing criteria offer comparable passing rates but are more accurate in selecting mild CVD. Nevertheless, military commanders should also consider specific operational requirements in selecting mild CVD for duty as reduced job performance may occur in a complex color critical environment.
Topics: Humans; Female; Male; Color Vision; Color Perception Tests; Military Personnel; Color Vision Defects; Cardiovascular Diseases
PubMed: 35352814
DOI: 10.1093/milmed/usac080 -
BMC Ophthalmology Mar 2022To assess dynamic visual acuity (DVA) under different defocus statuses and explore the assessment of dynamic vision accommodation.
BACKGROUND
To assess dynamic visual acuity (DVA) under different defocus statuses and explore the assessment of dynamic vision accommodation.
METHODS
Twenty subjects (6 males and 14 females) aged 18 to 35 were recruited. Nonmydriatic subjective refraction (sphere and cylinder) and accommodative tests including negative relative accommodation (NRA), positive relative accommodation (PRA), binocular cross cylinder (BCC) and accommodative facility using a flipper were performed. Binocular static visual acuity (SVA) and DVA at 40 degrees per second (dps) were measured under different defocus statuses (+1.5D to -4D in -0.5D steps) based on the refractive error fully corrected. Static and dynamic defocus curves were plotted. The area under the curve (AUC) and corrected dynamic vision accommodation (CDVAc) were calculated.
RESULTS
The study showed that the dynamic defocus curve fitted the cubic curve properly (p<0.001). DVA was significantly worse than SVA at all defocused statuses (p<0.001), and the difference was more significant at greater defocus diopters. Single factor analysis indicated that CDVAc was significantly correlated with NRA-PRA (p=0.012) and AUC (p<0.001). Significant associations were observed between AUC and PRA (p=0.013) as well as NRA-PRA (p=0.021). Meanwhile, DVA was positively correlated with PRA at 0D, -1.0D, -1.5D, -2.5D and -3.0D (p<0.05) and with NRA-PRA at 0D, -1.0D, -1.5D, -2.0D and -2.5D (p<0.05). Multiple factor regression analysis indicated that CDVAc (0D ~ -3.5D) and SVA (+1.5D ~ +1.0D & -2.5D ~ -4.0D) were significant influential factors for defocused DVA (p<0.05).
CONCLUSIONS
Our study demonstrated that DVA had a defocus curve similar to that of SVA. CDVAc was feasible for the assessment of dynamic vision accommodative function. The dynamic defocus curve test could efficiently be applied in the evaluation of dynamic visual performance under different defocus statuses.
Topics: Accommodation, Ocular; Adolescent; Adult; Female; Humans; Male; Refractive Errors; Vision Tests; Vision, Binocular; Visual Acuity; Young Adult
PubMed: 35248018
DOI: 10.1186/s12886-022-02335-9 -
Journal of Stroke and Cerebrovascular... Jun 2015We sought to explore the care provision for poststroke visual impairment and variations in this in the United Kingdom.
BACKGROUND
We sought to explore the care provision for poststroke visual impairment and variations in this in the United Kingdom.
METHODS
Survey questions were developed and piloted with clinicians, academics, and users. Questions addressed types of visual problems; how these were identified, treated, and followed up; care pathways in use; links with other professions; and referral options. The survey was accessed via a Weblink, which was circulated through UK professional organizations to multiprofessional members of ophthalmic and stroke teams.
RESULTS
A total of 548 completed electronic surveys were obtained. In all, 49.5% of respondents represented stroke teams, 42.5% eye teams, and 8% from other teams, for example, emergency care. Many respondents (41%) saw patients within 1 week of stroke. Nineteen percent did not personally test vision: 11% had a visiting clinician to test vision, and 22% used screening tools. Validated tests were used for the assessment of visual acuity (39.5%), visual field (57.5%), eye movement (48.5%), and visual function (58.5%). Visual problems suspected by family or professionals were high (88.5%). Typical overall follow-up period of vision care was less than 3 months. In all, 46% of respondents used designated care pathways for stroke survivors with visual problems; 33.5% of respondents did not provide visual information leaflets.
CONCLUSIONS
Significant inequality exists in care for stroke survivors who experience visual problems. There is great variability in how vision screening is undertaken, which vision tests are used, methods of referral to eye care services, how visual problems are managed, and what vision information is provided to stroke survivors/carers. Further work is required to ensure equality and effective care.
Topics: Health Care Surveys; Humans; Stroke; Vision Disorders; Vision Tests; Visual Acuity; Visual Fields
PubMed: 25920755
DOI: 10.1016/j.jstrokecerebrovasdis.2014.12.035 -
Journal of the Optical Society of... Mar 2023Questionnaires have been used as research tools to provide a standardized approach to assess quality of life at various time periods and populations. However, literature...
Questionnaires have been used as research tools to provide a standardized approach to assess quality of life at various time periods and populations. However, literature shows only a few articles about self-reported color vision changes. Our aim was to evaluate the subjective patient feelings before and after cataract surgery and compare the results with a color vision test result. Our method was as follows: 80 cataract patients filled out a modified color vision questionnaire and performed the Farnsworth-Munsell 100 Hue Color Vision Test (FM100) before, two weeks, and six months after cataract surgery. We analyzed the correlations between these two types of results, which reveal that FM100 hue performance and subjective perception improved after surgery. Additionally, subjective patient questionnaire scores correlate well with the FM100 test results before and two weeks after the cataract surgery, but this effect decreased with longer follow-up times. We conclude that subjective color vision changes can only be noticed at longer periods after the cataract surgery. Health care professionals can use this questionnaire to better understand the subjective feelings of patients and monitor their color vision sensitivity changes.
Topics: Humans; Color Vision; Color Perception; Quality of Life; Color Perception Tests; Cataract
PubMed: 37133024
DOI: 10.1364/JOSAA.477090 -
Romanian Journal of Ophthalmology 2020Idiopathic Intracranial Hypertension (IIH) is a disease of elevated intracranial pressure without any known cause. Visual dysfunction is the major morbidity of this...
Idiopathic Intracranial Hypertension (IIH) is a disease of elevated intracranial pressure without any known cause. Visual dysfunction is the major morbidity of this disease but not much is known about the way the contrast sensitivity (CS) function is affected. This prospective, interventional study attempted to evaluate the change in central and peripheral contrast sensitivity, after treatment in patients diagnosed with IIH. Twenty eyes of 10 IIH patients underwent an internet based, Spaeth Richman Contrast Sensitivity (SPARCS) test. Average and quadrant wise SPARCS scores were compared at presentation (treatment naïve), 1-month post treatment and 3 months post treatment. The average SPARCS scores pre-treatment, 1-month post-treatment and at 3 months post treatment were 68.8 + 10.16, 74.45 + 11.17 and 75.7 + 10.81 respectively. At 3 months visit, the average SPARCS score was nearly comparable to the average score in normal Indian subjects, observed in a previous study of ours. Quadrant wise change in contrast sensitivity from first visit to third visit was significant in superonasal (p=0.003), inferonasal (p=0.029) and inferotemporal (p= 0.007) quadrants. Effect of IIH on visual system is still a relatively unexplored area, especially in the Indians. Not many studies have concentrated on its impact on central as well as peripheral CS. Previous studies have hinted at a possible role of CS as a better indicator of visual dysfunction than other parameters. IIH affects both central and peripheral contrast sensitivity and therapy results in the improvement of contrast deficit. Poor contrast can possibly be explained by relatively more involvement of Magnocellular pathway over the Parvocellular pathway. IIH = Idiopathic Intracranial Hypertension, CS = Contrast Sensitivity, SPARCS = Spaeth Richman Contrast Sensitivity Test, BMI = Body Mass Index, MC = Magnocellular pathway, PC = Parvocellular pathway.
Topics: Adult; Contrast Sensitivity; Female; Follow-Up Studies; Humans; Male; Middle Aged; Prospective Studies; Pseudotumor Cerebri; Vision Tests; Visual Acuity; Visual Fields; Young Adult
PubMed: 33367175
DOI: 10.22336/rjo.2020.59 -
Journal of Dental Education Jun 2020The purpose of this study was to determine if there is an association between Perceptual Ability Test (PAT) results and color vision deficiency (CVD).
OBJECTIVE
The purpose of this study was to determine if there is an association between Perceptual Ability Test (PAT) results and color vision deficiency (CVD).
METHODS
Three consecutive classes of first-year dental students (n = 291) voluntarily participated in the study. The Farnsworth-Munsell 100 Hue Color Vision test (FM-100) was administered to students beneath a Macbeth Judge II viewing booth that provided ideal lighting conditions to ascertain CVD. Results of FM-100 test were recorded as total error scores (TES). Color acuity was scored as superior (TES 0-16), average (TES 20-100), or poor (TES > 100). Additional information of age, sex, ethnicity, and time to complete the FM-100 was obtained. Multiple linear regression was used to determine the association between PAT and CVD while adjusting for age, sex, ethnicity, and time to complete the FM-100 test.
RESULTS
TES ranged from 0-244. There were 132 students with superior color acuity, 161 with average, and eight with poor acuity. Females performed better than males on the FM-100 test. Time to complete the FM-100 test ranged from 3:40 minutes to 25:12 minutes. There was a strong relationship between PAT scores and CVD (P = 0.0003). A 1-unit increase in PAT scores was found to result in a 9% decrease in TES; indicating that students with higher PAT scores are less likely to have CVD.
CONCLUSION
The PAT may be a preliminary screening instrument to identify students who may have CVD. The FM-100 test can then confirm the presence of CVD. Students with CVD may desire to improve dental shade matching skills through targeted training and education.
Topics: Color; Color Perception; Color Perception Tests; Color Vision; Color Vision Defects; Female; Humans; Male
PubMed: 32077503
DOI: 10.1002/jdd.12111 -
Ophthalmic & Physiological Optics : the... Jan 2022The 3rd edition of the City University Colour Vision Test (CUT) was originally based on the Farnsworth-Munsell D-15 test (D15). The first part of the test is for...
INTRODUCTION
The 3rd edition of the City University Colour Vision Test (CUT) was originally based on the Farnsworth-Munsell D-15 test (D15). The first part of the test is for detecting a defect, and the second part is used to diagnose the type and severity of the defect. This study evaluates the CUT 3rd edition relative to the Ishihara and the D15 colour vision tests.
METHODS
Fifty nine colour vision normal subjects and 60 subjects with a congenital red-green colour vision defect were recruited. Subjects were tested with the Ishihara and CUT tests. Subjects who failed the Ishihara also performed the D15 test.
RESULTS
The agreement between the Ishihara and CUT screening plates was marginally higher when using the CUT failure criterion of >1 error compared with using >2 errors. If the diagnostic plates were included with the screening plates in determining the pass/fail outcomes, the agreement between the Ishihara and CUT was high, with a first-order agreement coefficient (AC1) of 0.90. The AC1 coefficient agreement between the D15 and CUT diagnostic plates in terms of pass/fail was 0.81 when using the D15 failure criteria of >1 or >0 crossing.
CONCLUSION
The level of agreement between the 3rd edition of the CUT and D15 was lower than the 2nd edition of the CUT. The primary reason for the lower agreement of the 3rd edition of the CUT was that it had a lower specificity relative to the D15 compared to the 2nd edition. Although the CUT predictive value for failing the D15 is over 90%, the predictive value for passing shows that 19%-25% of patients who pass the 3rd edition of the CUT test will fail the D15. The 3rd edition tends to misclassify protans as deutans or cannot classify the type of defect relative to the D15 and Ishihara.
Topics: Color Perception Tests; Color Vision; Color Vision Defects; Humans; Universities
PubMed: 34747057
DOI: 10.1111/opo.12915 -
Journal of Cataract and Refractive... Jul 2023To validate the Democritus Digital Acuity and Reading Test (DDART) as a distance VA (dVA) test against a series of prevalent conventional distance vision charts.
PURPOSE
To validate the Democritus Digital Acuity and Reading Test (DDART) as a distance VA (dVA) test against a series of prevalent conventional distance vision charts.
SETTING
Ophthalmology Department, University Hospital of Alexandroupolis, Alexandroupolis, Greece; Ophthalmology Department, AHEPA University Hospital, Thessaloniki, Greece; and Ophthalmica Institute of Ophthalmology & Microsurgery, Thessaloniki, Greece.
DESIGN
Prospective multicenter validation study.
METHODS
The distance best spectacle-corrected visual acuity (dBSCVA) was compared in normal (NVG) and low (LVG) vision participants against 4 prevalent conventional distance vision charts (ETDRS, Snellen, Landolt C, and Tumbling E) by a predefined 2.5-symbol noninferiority margin and intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs). DDART's test-retest (TRT) reliability was assessed with ICCs.
RESULTS
534 participants (471 and 63 with normal and low vision, respectively) were included in the study. The mean difference between dBSCVA measured with DDART and conventional charts ranged between -0.84 and +0.85 symbols, without exceeding the 2.5-symbol noninferiority margin. ICCs indicated an excellent level of agreement for all patient groups (from 0.848 to 0.985). TRT reliability indicated differences below 1 symbol both for the NVG and LVG, with ICCs ranging between 0.912 and 0.964 for the 4 DDARTs.
CONCLUSIONS
DDART was a valid web-based dVA test that provided reliable measurements in clinical and telemedical settings, both for normal and low vision patients.
Topics: Humans; Vision Tests; Vision, Low; Prospective Studies; Reproducibility of Results; Visual Acuity; Internet
PubMed: 36853857
DOI: 10.1097/j.jcrs.0000000000001176