-
Medecine Tropicale Et Sante... Dec 2023Scientific journals are the main source of scientific data, ensuring their registration, validation, distribution and archiving. With over 2.6 million scientific...
INTRODUCTION
Scientific journals are the main source of scientific data, ensuring their registration, validation, distribution and archiving. With over 2.6 million scientific articles published each year, the turnover of scientific journals exceeds $25 billion annually. Five publishers share nearly half of this lucrative market. Scientists are the key players in the process, but other stakeholders have gradually been introduced, building various business models whose similarities and differences are described here.
CONCEPTS UNDERLYING SCIENTIFIC PUBLICATION
Open access to scientific papers dates back to the scientific and technical revolution of the 17 century. However, its evolution has been considerably boosted by the development of the Internet and the recognition of science as "commons".Scientific integrity is under the control of research institutions to ensure the prevention of fraud and misconduct in the course of scientific production. Usually, the scientific integrity is questioned during the manuscript reviewing process which may result in identification of flaws.
MODELS OF SCIENTIFIC PUBLICATIONS
In the historical model, readers pay for access to the document. Authors are not remunerated and renounce copyright on their articles to the publisher. The limits of the historical model became clear in the 90s, facing the cost of publishing, reduction in the number of subscribers, development of the Internet and willingness to improve manuscript evaluation.With the development of the Internet and the paradigm of open access, publishers proposed a new model in the 2000s, replacing the cost of access to articles for the reader with the payment of Article Processing Charges (APCs) paid by the author or its institution ("author pays" model). In this model, the content of the article can be freely reproduced and used, provided that the original author is credited. In addition to the evaluation of the manuscript which remains a critical factor, the cost of publication appears inequitable. However, all or part of the APCs may be waived, particularly for authors from low- and middle-income countries.For the past 15 years or so, publishers, learned societies and academic or research institutions (including libraries) have been seeking to publish reliable, open access manuscripts that respect scientific integrity while being affordable for the author.Predatory journals emerged in the late 2000s, taking advantage of the success of the authorpays model to capture APCs. Lacking a proper evaluation process resulting in poor-quality publications, these journals are rejected by most scientific institutions. On the other hand, they are particularly attractive in low- and middle-income countries because of their aggressive commercial practices (insistent invitation to submit a manuscript, low rejection rate, rapid publication, reduced APC, etc.).The purpose of each journal is to secure its economic model. This goes through ensuring its visibility, which is determined by the number of citations (online and social media citations) rather than the quality of the articles published.
PEER REVIEW
This very old concept has not been widely used until the 20 century. In the historical model, manuscript evaluation is generally carried out by members of the learned society that publishes the journal. Evaluation can be either unblinded, single-blinded (referee is anonymous) or double-blinded (author and referee are anonymous). Several studies have shown that blind procedures do not alter the quality of the evaluation. Since the early 90s, post-publication evaluation has emerged, of which there are several variants. The aim is to shorten times to publication and open up the evaluation process more widely in order to limit the bias. Apart from the fact that this system does not guarantee a better evaluation of the manuscript, its main disadvantage is that the article is accessible without validation of the data collection and analysis throughout the entire process, which can be lengthy.
COST AND FUNDING OF SCIENTIFIC JOURNALS
The cost of an article depends on charges that vary according to the conditions and places of production. Reviewers are volunteers. On the other hand, manuscript management, editing and distribution are carried out by professionals, which entail financial charges. Some of these costs are lower in low- and medium-resource countries, where economies of scale and higher benefits are possible.
CONCLUSION
The limits of the historical model have led to the development of several business models of scientific journals, that are in constant evolution, especially the author pays model which promises open access to publications but impacts scientific production. However, the evaluation of scientific production is heterogeneous due to a limited pool of reviewers inadequately selected. Scientific publishing is looking for solutions to find a virtuous model that respects open science, open access to data and scientific integrity. The "Diamond open access" model, free of charge for both readers and authors with the guarantee of an irrevocable license to reproduce the content of the article provided that the original source is cited, perfectly fits.
Topics: Humans; Data Collection; Learning; Peer Review; Periodicals as Topic; Publishing; Science
PubMed: 38390021
DOI: 10.48327/mtsi.v3i4.2023.454 -
Cellular and Molecular Neurobiology Nov 2023This study employs bibliometric analysis through CiteSpace to comprehensively evaluate the status and trends of MANF (mesencephalic astrocyte-derived neurotrophic... (Review)
Review
This study employs bibliometric analysis through CiteSpace to comprehensively evaluate the status and trends of MANF (mesencephalic astrocyte-derived neurotrophic factor) research spanning 25 years (1997-2022). It aims to fill the gap in objective and comprehensive reviews of MANF research. MANF-related studies were extracted from the Web of Science database. MANF publications were quantitatively and qualitatively analyzed for various factors by CiteSpace, including publication volume, journals, countries/regions, institutions, and authors. Keywords and references were visually analyzed to unveil research evolution and hotspot. Analysis of 353 MANF-related articles revealed escalating annual publications, indicating growing recognition of MANF's importance. High-impact journals such as the International Journal of Molecular Sciences and Journal of Biological Chemistry underscored MANF's interdisciplinary significance. Collaborative networks highlighted China and the USA's pivotal roles, while influential figures and partnerships drove understanding of MANF's mechanisms. Co-word analysis of MANF-related keywords exposed key evolutionary hotspots, encompassing neurotrophic effects, cytoprotective roles, MANF-related diseases, and the CDNF/MANF family. This progression from basic understanding to clinical potential showcased MANF's versatility from cellular protection to therapy. Bibliometric analysis reveals MANF's diverse research trends and pathways, from basics to clinical applications, driving medical progress. This comprehensive assessment enriches understanding and empowers researchers for dynamic evolution, advancing innovation, and benefiting patients. Bibliometric analysis of MANF research. The graphical abstract depicts the bibliometric analysis of MANF research, highlighting its aims, methods, and key results.
Topics: Humans; Nerve Growth Factors; Bibliometrics; Biomedical Research
PubMed: 37751132
DOI: 10.1007/s10571-023-01412-x -
Proceedings. Biological Sciences Jul 2023Women are underrepresented in senior academic positions within microbiology globally. Studies show that gender bias affects the progression of women in academia, but... (Review)
Review
Women are underrepresented in senior academic positions within microbiology globally. Studies show that gender bias affects the progression of women in academia, but there is evidence that improving conscious awareness of bias can improve equity in this regard. Here we analyse the publication data associated with review articles within the microbiology field to investigate the statistical associations with author gender. We analyse the data from review articles published between 2010 and 2022 in three leading microbiology review journals: , and . We find a significant association between the gender of the lead author and the gender of co-authors in multi-author publications. Review articles with men lead authors have a significantly reduced proportion of women co-authors compared to reviews with women lead authors. Given the existing differences in the proportions of men and women in lead author positions, this association may have important consequences for the relative visibility of women in microbiology, along with negative impacts on scientific output relating to reduced collaboration diversity.
Topics: Humans; Male; Female; Authorship; Publishing; Sexism; Consciousness
PubMed: 37403511
DOI: 10.1098/rspb.2023.0965 -
Medicine Sep 2023Fertility concerns are a pervasive issue but very subtle in patients with cancer. Though various studies have focused on fertility concerns, limited research endeavor... (Review)
Review
Fertility concerns are a pervasive issue but very subtle in patients with cancer. Though various studies have focused on fertility concerns, limited research endeavor has been dedicated to bibliometric analysis. Given this, to visually analyze the hot frontier trends of research related to fertility concerns of patients with cancer using CiteSpace and provide new insights for future research in this field using the bibliometric method. We used CiteSpace software to retrieve the literature related to fertility concerns of patients with cancer in the Web of Science core collection database from the year of establishment to 2022 and conducted visual analysis in terms of authors, countries and regions, research institutions, and keywords. The search resulted in 201 valid articles, and the annual publication volume of literature related to fertility concerns in patients with cancer was generally on the rise; the country with the most publications was the United States, which also had the highest influence; the main research institution was Sloan Kettleson Cancer Research Center; the core research scholar was Jessica R. Gorman; the research hotspots mainly centered on quality of survival, women, survivorship, preservation, breast cancer, adolescence, and infertility. The results of this bibliometric study provide the current status and trends in the fertility concerns of patients with cancer and may help researchers identify the hotspots and frontier trends in this field.
Topics: Adolescent; Humans; Female; Fertility; Breast Neoplasms; Infertility; Health Facilities; Bibliometrics
PubMed: 37746999
DOI: 10.1097/MD.0000000000035211 -
American Journal of Veterinary Research Apr 2024
Topics: Periodicals as Topic; Veterinary Medicine; Editorial Policies
PubMed: 38697187
DOI: 10.2460/ajvr.85.05.editorial -
Drug Design, Development and Therapy 2023The objective of this study is to conduct a bibliometric analysis of the present status, areas of focus, and upcoming developments in the research of anesthetic drugs...
OBJECTIVE
The objective of this study is to conduct a bibliometric analysis of the present status, areas of focus, and upcoming developments in the research of anesthetic drugs and their impact on immune function, along with other related research domains.
METHODS
From January 1, 2008 to June 9, 2023, A thorough exploration of anesthetic drug-related literature pertaining to immune function was carried out through the utilization of the Web of Science. The bibliometric analysis was predominantly executed by means of CiteSpace, GraphPad Prism 8.0, and the acquisition of data regarding the country, institution, author, journal, and keywords associated with each publication.
RESULTS
This study analyzed a comprehensive total of 318 publications, consisting of 228 articles and 90 reviews, to determine the publication output of anesthetic drugs on immune function. Notably, China exhibited the highest publication output with (109, 34.28%) articles. Among the institutions analyzed, Harvard University was found to be the most productive with (12, 3.77%) publications. The study findings indicate that Buggy, Donal J (5, 1.57%) and Yuki, Koichi (5, 1.57%) had the highest publication records. Anesthesiology was the most frequently cited journal with a total of (206) citations. The results also revealed that "surgery" was the most frequently used keyword, appearing (48 times), followed by "general anesthesia" (41 times) and "breast cancer" (37 times). The study has identified several current areas of interest, with a particular emphasis on "metastasis", "inflammation", "recurrence", "anesthesia technique", and "induction". It is anticipated that forthcoming research endeavors will concentrate on exploring the impacts of isoflurane, sevoflurane, and ketamine on immune function.
CONCLUSION
This study provided a thorough analysis of the research trends and developments in investigating the impact of anesthetic drugs on immune function, incorporating pertinent research and collaborative entities such as authors, institutions, and countries.
Topics: Humans; Anesthetics; Isoflurane; Bibliometrics; Anesthesia, General; Immunity
PubMed: 37908313
DOI: 10.2147/DDDT.S433629 -
Global Health Research and Policy Nov 2023Collaborative research between the global north and global south is common and growing in number. Due to inability of local governments to fund research, global north... (Review)
Review
Collaborative research between the global north and global south is common and growing in number. Due to inability of local governments to fund research, global north actors provide the bulk of research funding. While providing mutual benefits, global collaborative research projects are far from ideal. In this paper, we review the authorship discrepancies in global collaborative research, discuss preventive measures in place and their shortfalls, and recommend an intervention to address the problem. Malawi research guidelines recommend collaboration between foreign and local researchers in locally conducted research. However, there is no provision requiring joint authorship in final published papers. Journal recommendations on authorship criteria exist, but they can disadvantage low- and middle-income country researchers in collaborative projects because of exclusionary interpretations of guidelines. For example, the requirement for authors to make substantial contributions to conception or design of the work may favor research grant holders, often from the global north. Systematic and holistic changes proposed to address power asymmetries at the core of the problem have been proposed. However, these proposals may take a long time to produce change. Ad interim, local institutions can take more direct action to address inequalities by establishing offices of research integrity to enforce mandates to increase opportunities for authorship in collaborative research.
Topics: Authorship; Developing Countries; Global Health; Internationality; Publications
PubMed: 37993933
DOI: 10.1186/s41256-023-00334-x -
Medicine Dec 2023Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) has evolved from a narrow and rare childhood-onset disorder to a widely publicized and researched lifelong disease recognized as common...
Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) has evolved from a narrow and rare childhood-onset disorder to a widely publicized and researched lifelong disease recognized as common and significantly heterogeneous. Researchers have suggested that gastrointestinal symptoms in ASD may be a manifestation of an underlying inflammatory process. However, there is a lack of bibliometric analysis of ASD and gut microbiota in children. Accordingly, this study conducts a bibliometric analysis of ASD and gut microbiota in children from 2000 to 2023, explores the current status and cutting-edge trends in the field of ASD and gut microbiota in children, and identifies new directions for future research. The literature on ASD and gut microbiota in children was screened using the Web of Science Core Collection from 2000 to 2023. Annual publications, countries, institutions, authors, journals, keywords, and references were visualized and analyzed using CiteSpace 5.8. R3 and VOSviewer1.6.18. This study included 1071 publications. Since the beginning of 2011, the overall number of articles shows an upward trend. The most productive country and institution are the United States and the University of California system, respectively. The most frequently cited author is Kang Dae-Wook, with 790 citations, who has contributed significantly to this field. Timothy Dinan is the most prolific author, with 34 articles. The journal with the most published articles on this topic is Nutrients, whereas PLOS One is the most cited journal. The most used keyword is "gut microbiota," and the reference for the highest outbreak intensity is Hsiao. The research hotspots and trends predicted in this study provide a reference for further in-depth research in this field.
Topics: Child; Humans; Gastrointestinal Microbiome; Autism Spectrum Disorder; Bibliometrics; Disease Outbreaks; Health Facilities; Rare Diseases
PubMed: 38206702
DOI: 10.1097/MD.0000000000036794 -
BMJ Open Oct 2023Reference intervals and reference curves provide clinicians with a point of reference when evaluating patients' laboratory test results. In practical applications, the...
INTRODUCTION
Reference intervals and reference curves provide clinicians with a point of reference when evaluating patients' laboratory test results. In practical applications, the 2.5th and 97.5th percentiles of healthy reference population are typically used as lower and upper reference limits. Guidelines outlining analytical and methodological steps involved in reference intervals and curves estimation are available and there have been large-scale world-wide initiatives to provide reference intervals and curves for children. However, there is a lack of synthesised evidence regarding the results of such initiatives in general, but specifically in iron-related biomarkers, ferritin (in serum and plasma) and haemoglobin. Objectives of this review are to identify studies that have produced reference intervals and curves for ferritin and haemoglobin in paediatric populations and to synthesise all available evidence. We also aim to quantify heterogeneity across reference intervals and curves and identify and elucidate sources of heterogeneity, including heterogeneity in the methods employed in their development.
METHODS AND ANALYSIS
Using a comprehensive search strategy, we will identify eligible studies. Following electronic databases will be searched from inception: EMBASE, MEDLINE, SCOPUS and The Cochrane Library. We will also perform grey literature search to capture unpublished reference intervals and curves from healthy cohorts. Two researchers will independently screen retrieved citations against eligibility criteria in two stages, focusing first on titles and abstracts and then on full-text articles. Studies that provide reference intervals and curves for ferritin and haemoglobin for paediatric population will be eligible. Data extraction will include study characteristics, characteristics of reference population, methodological and analytical considerations and estimated reference intervals and curves. We will consider narrative synthesis and quantitative synthesis when appropriate.
ETHICS AND DISSEMINATION
Ethical approval is not required as data from already published studies will be used. Results will be disseminated through peer-reviewed publications and conference presentations.
PROSPERO REGISTRATION NUMBER
CRD42023399802.
Topics: Humans; Child; Ferritins; Systematic Reviews as Topic; Meta-Analysis as Topic; Hemoglobins; Peer Review; Research Design; Review Literature as Topic
PubMed: 37793936
DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2023-073783 -
BMJ Open Aug 2023Problematic sleep is a major threat to health and quality of life among adolescents. Hence, to provide directions for research and interventions, there is a need to...
INTRODUCTION
Problematic sleep is a major threat to health and quality of life among adolescents. Hence, to provide directions for research and interventions, there is a need to examine the literature on adolescent sleep health in Africa. However, available studies on adolescent sleep health in Africa have not been properly mapped. Thus, this scoping review aims to investigate the extent and type of available evidence concerning sleep health among adolescents in Africa and to highlight the relationship of adolescent sleep health with adverse mental health outcomes and cardiometabolic risk factors. The review will further highlight areas of agreement and controversies on adolescent sleep health, and identify evidence gaps that require research attention across the continent.
METHODS AND ANALYSIS
This scoping review will be conducted using Arksey and O'Malley's six-step procedure. Thus, we have prepared this protocol according to the framework for scoping reviews developed by the Joanna Briggs Institute. To identify eligible studies, we will search MEDLINE, Scopus, PsycINFO, AJOL, JSTOR, HINARI and Google Scholar. The review will include all published articles in English, French, Spanish, Portuguese and Italian languages on adolescent sleep health in Africa from the inception of the databases, while relevant information will be extracted from included studies using an adapted data extraction tool. The results will be presented using tables and charts as appropriate.
ETHICS AND DISSEMINATION
The scoping review does not require ethical approval because the publications to be used for the review are publicly available and the study does not involve contact with humans or other animals as research participants. Furthermore, clinical records will not be used for the study. Upon completion, findings from the study will be disseminated through presentations at scientific meetings and publication in a relevant peer-reviewed journal.
SCOPING REVIEW REGISTRATION
Open Science Framework (https://osf.io/5sjwq/).
Topics: Animals; Humans; Adolescent; Quality of Life; Academies and Institutes; Adolescent Health; Africa; Sleep; Review Literature as Topic
PubMed: 37591652
DOI: 10.1136/bmjopen-2022-067373