-
Journal of Athletic Training Jun 2024An emergency action plan (EAP) is a written document detailing the preparations and on-site emergency response of health care professionals and other stakeholders to...
OBJECTIVE
An emergency action plan (EAP) is a written document detailing the preparations and on-site emergency response of health care professionals and other stakeholders to medical emergencies in the prehospital setting. The EAP is developed to address any type of catastrophic injury response and should not be condition specific. The objective of this National Athletic Trainers' Association position statement is to provide evidence-based and consensus-based recommendations for developing and implementing an EAP for sports settings.
METHODS
These recommendations were developed by a multidisciplinary expert panel that performed (1) a comprehensive review of existing EAP evidence, (2) a modified Delphi process to define consensus recommendations, and (3) a strength of recommendation taxonomy determination for each recommendation.
RESULTS
An EAP is an essential tool designed to facilitate emergency preparedness and an efficient, coordinated emergency response during an athletic event. A comprehensive EAP should consider modes to optimize patient outcomes, the various stakeholders needed to develop the plan, the factors influencing effective implementation of the EAP, and the roles and responsibilities to ensure a structured response to a catastrophic injury.
CONCLUSIONS
These evidence-informed recommendations outline the necessary steps for emergency planning and provide considerations for the immediate management of patients with catastrophic injuries. Increasing knowledge and implementation of the EAP to manage patients with catastrophic injuries improves the overall response and decreases errors during an emergency.
Topics: Humans; Athletic Injuries; Emergency Medical Services; Sports Medicine; Consensus; Delphi Technique; Sports
PubMed: 38918009
DOI: 10.4085/1062-6050-0521.23 -
The British Journal of Surgery Jun 2024
Development of an ontology for laparoscopic transabdominal adrenalectomy via a comprehensive modified Delphi survey and its validation on a multicentric pilot data set for surgical training and future video analysis with machine learning algorithms.
Topics: Humans; Adrenalectomy; Laparoscopy; Delphi Technique; Machine Learning; Pilot Projects; Video Recording
PubMed: 38916133
DOI: 10.1093/bjs/znae148 -
Neurology. Clinical Practice Aug 2024Spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is an autosomal recessive progressive neurodegenerative primary motor neuron disorder caused by biallelic variants of the survival motor...
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES
Spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) is an autosomal recessive progressive neurodegenerative primary motor neuron disorder caused by biallelic variants of the survival motor neuron 1 () gene. The most recent SMA best practice recommendations were published in 2018 shortly after the approval of the first SMN-enhancing treatment. The availability of disease-modifying therapies for 5q SMA and implementation of SMA newborn screening (NBS) has led to urgency to update the SMA best practice recommendations for diagnosis and to reevaluate the current classification of SMA. In addition, the availability of disease-modifying therapies has opened the door to explore improved diagnosis of adult-onset SMA.
METHODS
A systematic literature review was conducted on SMA NBS. An SMA working group of American and European health care providers developed recommendations through a modified Delphi technique with serial surveys and virtual meeting feedback on SMA diagnosis to fill information gaps for topics with limited evidence. A community working group of an individual with SMA and caregivers provided insight and perspective on SMA diagnosis and support through a virtual meeting to guide recommendations.
RESULTS
The health care provider working group achieved consensus that SMA NBS is essential to include in the updated best practice for SMA diagnosis (100%). Recommendations for the following are described: characterizing NBS-identified infants before treatment; minimum recommendations for starting or offering SMA NBS in a state or country; recommendations for activities and services to be provided by an SMA specialty care center accepting SMA NBS referrals; and recommendations for partnership with individuals with SMA and caregivers to support NBS-identified infants and their caregivers. Limited data are available to advance efficient diagnosis of adult-onset SMA.
DISCUSSION
Updating best practice recommendations for SMA diagnosis to include SMA NBS implementation is essential to advancing care for individuals with SMA. In addition to testing, processes for the efficient management of positive newborn screen with access to knowledgeable and skilled health care providers and access to treatment options is critical to successful early diagnosis. Additional evidence is required to improve adult-onset SMA diagnosis.
PubMed: 38915908
DOI: 10.1212/CPJ.0000000000200310 -
BMC Medical Informatics and Decision... Jun 2024This study aimed to develop and validate a quantitative index system for evaluating the data quality of Electronic Medical Records (EMR) in disease risk prediction using...
OBJECTIVE
This study aimed to develop and validate a quantitative index system for evaluating the data quality of Electronic Medical Records (EMR) in disease risk prediction using Machine Learning (ML).
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The index system was developed in four steps: (1) a preliminary index system was outlined based on literature review; (2) we utilized the Delphi method to structure the indicators at all levels; (3) the weights of these indicators were determined using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) method; and (4) the developed index system was empirically validated using real-world EMR data in a ML-based disease risk prediction task.
RESULTS
The synthesis of review findings and the expert consultations led to the formulation of a three-level index system with four first-level, 11 second-level, and 33 third-level indicators. The weights of these indicators were obtained through the AHP method. Results from the empirical analysis illustrated a positive relationship between the scores assigned by the proposed index system and the predictive performances of the datasets.
DISCUSSION
The proposed index system for evaluating EMR data quality is grounded in extensive literature analysis and expert consultation. Moreover, the system's high reliability and suitability has been affirmed through empirical validation.
CONCLUSION
The novel index system offers a robust framework for assessing the quality and suitability of EMR data in ML-based disease risk predictions. It can serve as a guide in building EMR databases, improving EMR data quality control, and generating reliable real-world evidence.
Topics: Electronic Health Records; Humans; Machine Learning; Data Accuracy; Risk Assessment; Delphi Technique
PubMed: 38915008
DOI: 10.1186/s12911-024-02533-z -
Scientific Reports Jun 2024Psoriasis is a chronic skin disease that negatively impacts on patient's life. A holistic approach integrating well-being assessment could improve disease management....
Psoriasis is a chronic skin disease that negatively impacts on patient's life. A holistic approach integrating well-being assessment could improve disease management. Since a consensus definition of well-being in psoriasis is not available, we aim to achieve a multidisciplinary consensus on well-being definition and its components. A literature review and consultation with psoriasis patients facilitated the design of a two-round Delphi questionnaire targeting healthcare professionals and psoriasis patients. A total of 261 panellists (65.1% patients with psoriasis, 34.9% healthcare professionals) agreed on the dimensions and components that should integrate the concept of well-being: emotional dimension (78.9%) [stress (83.9%), mood disturbance (85.1%), body image (83.9%), stigma/shame (75.1%), self-esteem (77.4%) and coping/resilience (81.2%)], physical dimension (82.0%) [sleep quality (81.6%), pain/discomfort (80.8%), itching (83.5%), extracutaneous manifestations (82.8%), lesions in visible areas (84.3%), lesions in functional areas (85.8%), and sex life (78.2%)], social dimension (79.5%) [social relationships (80.8%), leisure/recreational activities (80.3%), support from family/friends (76.6%) and work/academic life (76.5%)], and satisfaction with disease management (78.5%) [treatment (78.2%), information received (75.6%) and medical care provided by the dermatologist (80.1%)]. This well-being definition reflects patients' needs and concerns. Therefore, addressing them in psoriasis will optimise management, contributing to better outcomes and restoring normalcy to the patient's life.
Topics: Humans; Psoriasis; Health Personnel; Delphi Technique; Female; Male; Surveys and Questionnaires; Consensus; Adult; Quality of Life; Middle Aged; Self Concept
PubMed: 38914574
DOI: 10.1038/s41598-024-64738-6 -
Revista Brasileira de Ortopedia Jun 2024This study aimed to describe the methodological process for developing a questionnaire to identify the prevalence and risk factors for chronic occupational low back...
This study aimed to describe the methodological process for developing a questionnaire to identify the prevalence and risk factors for chronic occupational low back pain in healthcare professionals working at hospitals. An exploratory crossectional survey study was carried out in Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil, and its metropolitan region, in two stages. Initially, the authors prepared a questionnaire based on the Roland Morris disability questionnaire and sent it to a committee of low back pain specialists for validation using the Delphi technique. The second stage consisted of sending the final questionnaire to health professionals working in a hospital environment for at least 2 years and presenting chronic low back pain for at least 3 months. Validation occurred in two rounds of questionnaire adjustments by a panel consisting of physical therapists and physician experts in the field (orthopedists with more than 3 years of experience). Both rounds had 13 participants. The questionnaire initially consisted of 27 items, and, after validation, it had 19 items. The study included 65 subjects, with an average age of 40.91 years old and an average time working at a hospital of 40 hours per week. The total sample had 76.9% of physicians, 10.8% of physical therapists, and 12.3% of nurses or nursing technicians. Most (52.3%) subjects reported staying in uncomfortable positions affecting the lower back for 5 to 10 hours per day. We developed and validated, using the Delphi technique, a questionnaire on the prevalence and risk factors associated with chronic occupational low back pain among healthcare professionals working at hospitals. This unprecedented tool can benefit the population studied since the questionnaires currently used to evaluate chronic low back pain are not specific for investigating the occupational cause of this condition.
PubMed: 38911888
DOI: 10.1055/s-0044-1786729 -
Nursing Outlook Jun 2024Health policy critically influences a national healthcare system and nurse's roles, working conditions, and professional development opportunities, especially in low-...
BACKGROUND
Health policy critically influences a national healthcare system and nurse's roles, working conditions, and professional development opportunities, especially in low- and middle-income countries.
PURPOSE
To explore and prioritize the major challenges and solution, and establish policy directions for improving nursing education in the Kyrgyz Republic.
METHODS
The key stakeholders of nursing practice, education, policymaking, and regulation were involved in this modified Delphi study. Following two rounds of exploring priority issues and potential strategies, the participants of the final round assembled for consensual discussions on the establishment of policy directions.
DISCUSSION
Innovations in nursing education systems, building educational capacity, and ensuring educational outcomes were suggested and agreed upon for the sequential improvement of nursing education. Timely enactment of these policies will enable the Kyrgyz Republic to mitigate nursing shortages, improve the quality of healthcare services, and enhance overall public health outcomes.
CONCLUSION
The policy suggestions derived from this study, including the improvement of nursing education quality and the assurance of nurses' competencies, have great potential for improving quality healthcare practice and sustaining an effective healthcare system.
PubMed: 38908293
DOI: 10.1016/j.outlook.2024.102222 -
Sante Publique (Vandoeuvre-les-Nancy,... 2024Health professionals’ social responsibility in health resists translation into skills that can be taught and implemented concretely in professional practice.
INTRODUCTION
Health professionals’ social responsibility in health resists translation into skills that can be taught and implemented concretely in professional practice.
PURPOSE OF THE RESEARCH
This study, conducted by the Réseau International Francophone pour la Responsabilité Sociale en Santé (RIFRESS), aims to develop a consensus on the components of doctors’ social responsibility in health from the perspective of experts in medical education. Its findings are intended to inform the creation of a skills profile. A three-round Delphi consensus method was used, with an open first round and closed second and third rounds. Mesydel software was used to organize the process and to do the qualitative analysis of the first round. SPSS was used for consensus analysis for rounds 2 and 3.
RESULTS
Thirty-four experts responded to the study. During the first round, 62 codes emerged, grouped into 13 themes. From the initial analysis, 40 items were submitted for the Delphi round 2. Of these 40 items, 23 came out consensual after the second round, as did 13 of the 18 resubmitted items after the third. Examples of items that emerged as consensual are eco-responsibility, advocacy, defense of the common good, critical analysis of practice, and collaborative leadership.
CONCLUSIONS
The present study represents a much-needed effort to concretely define the components of doctors’ social responsibility in health. Local context must be taken into account when using these findings. They can help to train tomorrow’s doctors to better meet the priority health needs of society in a profoundly changing world.
Topics: Delphi Technique; Humans; Social Responsibility; Internationality; Consensus; Female; Male
PubMed: 38906818
DOI: No ID Found -
Journal of Hand Surgery Global Online Mar 2024The aim of this study was to establish the consensus recommendations among hand surgeons who were experts in the use of collagenase clostridium histolyticum (CCH) on the...
PURPOSE
The aim of this study was to establish the consensus recommendations among hand surgeons who were experts in the use of collagenase clostridium histolyticum (CCH) on the appropriate treatment of Dupuytren disease in well-defined patient populations with varying degrees of disease severity and functional impairment.
METHODS
A three-round, blinded, modified Delphi process examined panelists' approaches to CCH treatment of metacarpophalangeal (MP) or proximal interphalangeal (PIP) joint contractures involving one or two fingers with varying degrees of severity. Clinical scenarios related to poor-quality skin, postfasciectomy scarring, boutonnière deformity, closed capsulotomy, and blood thinner use were also presented for panelist consideration. Panelists provided responses to clinical scenarios using a 5-point Likert scale or a yes/no response. Consensus was defined as ≥66.7% panelist agreement or disagreement.
RESULTS
Twenty panelists completed round 1; 19 of the 20 panelists completed rounds 2 and 3. Panelists achieved a high level of consensus for using CCH for the treatment of patients with palpable cords and varying severity contractures representing one- or two-finger MP joint contractures, most one- or two-finger PIP joint contractures, and most combined MP and PIP joint contractures. Consensus for the treatment of PIP joint contractures was mostly achieved, but clinical scenarios related to recurrent PIP contracture with poor-quality skin and/or significant postfasciectomy scarring, boutonnière deformity, PIP contractures >70°, closed capsulotomy, and blood thinner use were modified, and then most (95.3%) statements reached consensus for agreement in round 2. In round 3, open-ended responses indicated that panelists considered CCH appropriate for most patients with Dupuytren disease.
CONCLUSIONS
Consensus-based findings among expert hand surgeons with substantial CCH experience indicated that CCH has a wide-ranging application for the treatment of Dupuytren disease in patients with varying degrees of disease severity and functional impairment.
TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE
Therapeutic V.
PubMed: 38903838
DOI: 10.1016/j.jhsg.2023.10.011 -
Pediatrics Jul 2024To develop guidance for pediatric clinicians on how to discuss race and racism in pediatric clinical settings.
OBJECTIVE
To develop guidance for pediatric clinicians on how to discuss race and racism in pediatric clinical settings.
METHODS
We conducted a modified Delphi study from 2021 to 2022 with a panel of pediatric clinicians, psychologists, parents, and adolescents with expertise in racism and child health through scholarship or lived experience. Panelists responded to an initial survey with open-ended questions about how to talk to youth about race and racism. We coded the responses using qualitative methods and presented them back to the panelists. In iterative surveys, panelists reached a consensus on which themes were most important for the conversation.
RESULTS
A total of 29 of 33 panelists completed the surveys and a consensus was reached about the concepts pediatric clinicians should consider before, during, and after conversations about race and racism and impediments clinicians may face while having these discussions. Panelists agreed that it was within the pediatric clinician's role to have these conversations. An overarching theme was the importance of having background knowledge about the systemic nature of racism. Panelists agreed that being active listeners, learning from patients, and addressing intersectionality were important for pediatric clinicians during conversations. Panelists also agreed that short- and long-term benefits may result from these conversations; however, harm could be done if pediatric clinicians do not have adequate training to conduct the conversations.
CONCLUSIONS
These principles can help guide conversations about race and racism in the pediatric clinical setting, equipping clinicians with tools to offer care that acknowledges and addresses the racism many of their patients face.
Topics: Humans; Racism; Child; Pediatrics; Communication; Delphi Technique; Physician-Patient Relations; Adolescent; Pediatricians; Racial Groups; Female; Male
PubMed: 38903051
DOI: 10.1542/peds.2023-063767